Colt 9mm SMG vs PP-19 Vityaz: Ergonomics and Performance in Military Combat
The Key Question:
Are you Russian-trained or US/Canadian or other AR15/M16-trained? Short barreled, closed bolt 9mm submachine guns with proper ergonomics are fairly basic and comparable depending on training. The PP-19 inherits its ergonomics from AK’s, while the Colt 9mm SMG inherits its ergonomics from the AR15/M16 family. Therefore, the people who have extensive experience with a particular family of weapons will have an advantage in a close quarters fight because their brain is focused on the fight, not on operating the gun.
Performance Comparison
Both the Colt 9mm submachinegun and the PP-19 Vityaz operate on a straight blowback closed bolt system. However, they share some differences in design that affect their performance in military combat.
Ergonomics and User Experience
The ergonomics of the weapons play a crucial role in their performance. The PP-19 Vityaz, designed with features similar to the AK-74, has a well-designed grip and reciprocating thumb ramps. These features are favored by those trained in Russian combat systems, offering a better shooting experience for them. On the other hand, the Colt 9mm SMG, based on the M-16, has an ergonomically designed grip and magazine catch that align with the AR15/M16 training background. For US/Canadian or other AR15/M16-trained soldiers, the Colt 9mm SMG provides a familiar and comfortable shooting experience.
Operational Mechanics and Controllability
The operational mechanics of both submachine guns involve high-pressure firing that causes significant movement during full auto firing. This inherent feature affects the controllability of the weapons. Both the Colt and PP-19 Vityaz suffer from this issue, making them less controllable compared to the MP-5, which has a delayed roller blowback system. The MP-5’s system uses a lighter bolt and spring, making it far more manageable during rapid fire.
Conclusion
The choice between the Colt 9mm SMG and the PP-19 Vityaz ultimately depends on the training background of the user. The ergonomic design of the weapons is critical, as it can significantly influence performance. While both weapons share similarities in their design and performance, the most critical aspects of a handheld machineguncontrollability and reliabilityplace the MP-5 in a superior position.
Related Keywords: Colt 9mm SMG, PP-19 Vityaz, Military Combat, Ergonomics, Controllability