The Ultimate Guide: Drano vs Drain Machine for Unblocking Bathtubs

Dealing with a clogged bathtub can be frustrating, but the choice between using Drano or a drain machine largely depends on the type of clog, the age of your home, and the materials involved. This guide will help you determine the best method and offer alternatives that are equally effective without the potential hazards.

Understanding the Types of Clogs

Before choosing a method, it's important to understand the type of clog you're faced with. The most common clogs occur in bathtubs with lead or PVC pipes. If the stoppage is at the transition to cast iron, you're dealing with lead pipes, while PVC lines indicate a clog within the shower where the plug goes.

Chemical Drain Cleaners: A No-No

Chemical drain cleaners like Drano, while seemingly effective, can be highly toxic and damaging to your pipes. They often contain harsh chemicals that can erode and corrode pipe walls, leading to leaks and further plumbing issues. It's recommended to avoid these as a first resort.

Alternative Methods: Enzyme Cleaners and Physical Removal

For chronic clogs, using an enzyme cleaner can be a better option. Unlike chemical cleaners, enzyme cleaners break down buildup without damaging pipes. However, it may take time, usually about ten days, to clear the clog effectively.

DIY Removal Methods

For those who prefer a more hands-on approach, several DIY methods can be quite effective:

Shop Vacuum and DIY Hook

If you have a lever-operated stopper, start by pulling it out and using a shop vac to suck out as much water as possible. Then, use a zip tie with the tip bent over to form a hook and some forceps to remove hair. Finish by rinsing with hot water to clear the drain. If this doesn't work:

Wiring Hanger Method

Reach down past the drain with a straightened wire clothes hanger, and fashion a tiny hook at the end with pliers. Jiggle it around until you feel clumps of hair, then pull them out. If it gets stuck, lower it a little, turn, and lift again until it comes loose. This is a simple yet effective method to clear most clogs.

Snake Through the Overflow

Removing the overflow plate and stopper assembly can reveal further clogs. After pulling off any accumulated hair, reassemble in reverse. If these methods fail, you can try snaking the drain through the overflow.

Conclusion

For most home clogs, a combination of DIY methods is often the most effective and safest approach. Chemical cleaners should be your last resort due to potential hazards. By understanding the type of clog and using the right tools, you can clear your bathtub without breaking a sweat or risking damage to your pipes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I do if the clog is particularly stubborn?

Use a combination of the hanger method and enzyme cleaner. For more persistent issues, consult a professional plumber.

Can I use a wire hanger without any tools?

While a wire hanger can work without additional tools, using a bent tip and pliers can make the process more effective.

How often should I clear my bathtub drain?

Regular removal of hair and debris is recommended every month or so to prevent clogs. If you notice a buildup, it's a good idea to clear it immediately.